Oratory has a long and noble history. In ancient Greece, oratory was considered a necessary part of the study of rhetoric and was a required part of a well-rounded education. The British parliament has famously placed a high regard on the skilled delivery of speeches from the floor. And even some our own politicians of the past have inspired their fellow Americans with stirring speeches and linguistic flourishes (though not, of course, our current idiot of a President).
But nowhere is oration more alive today than in the vast megachurches and evangelical temples of our nation's embarrassingly large Christian population. As a subgenre of oratory, preaching can turn even the most contradictory, head-scratchinging, mind-numbingly silly passages of the Bible into powerful theater with the ability to brainwash weak minds.
And though there are a number of eloquent atheist writers enjoying a higher profile these days (e.g. Christopher Hitchens and Richard Dawkins), they can hardly be described as "charismatic." Dawkins is easily disregarded by believers who simply object to his perceived arrogance and snarkiness, and the acerbic Hitchens is generally entertaining, but again, only when he's preaching (sic) to the converted (sic).
I generally regard Sam Harris, author of The End of Faith and Letter to a Christian Nation (and discussed on this blog [EndOfFaith|here]), as the most level-headed and persuasive of all the big-name anti-theists out there today. Sure he goes on a bit much about "spirituality," but he not overtly offensively and mocking.
Recently, I found a podcast (fancy word for "MP3 file that you can download") of Harris' talk at something called the "Aspen Ideas Festival." (Listen!) In it Harris explains very patiently and convincingly explains why he believes religion and theism do more harm than good in the world.
He's exceedingly logical and articulate.
And boring!
Would it hurt the guy to use some intonation? I'm not asking for any "Can I get a 'Hallalujah!'" or anything, but maybe a bit more range to the volume would be nice. The guy even had some pretty funny lines, and then steps all over himself when the audience starts laughing.
We atheists need impassioned, powerful speakers. What has happened to the Clarence Darrows? The Bertrand Russells? Where have all the atheist orators gone?
I really respect and admire Sam Harris, and I think the speech he gave was spot on, and may even possess several points that would make actual believers stop and say: "Hmmmm. I never thought of that." But I doubt any of them would get past the first 5 minutes. I only did because I was on an elliptical machine at the gym when I listened and if I tried to change the channel on my MP3 player, I would have strangled myself.
Again, this is not to dis Mr. Harris' arguments. This talk contained some of the most reasoned arguments against theism and religion that I've ever heard. It was well-organized. It was exhaustively researched. It was also as dry as a nun's gusset.
Nevertheless, I do recommend it to all believers and non-believers out there who happen upon this infrequently-updated little patch of teh internets, and I would welcome your comments on it.
(Again, that link is: http://download.publicradio.org/podcast/wordforword/2007/09/070914_wfw_64.mp3